Career guides

How to ask for feedback in your first job

In a first job, nobody can see what you are unsure about unless you say. Asking for feedback is one of the simplest ways to learn how your work is received and what to improve. It can feel awkward, especially with a busy manager, so a specific, well-timed question helps. Some managers give more feedback than others, and that says little about your work.

Vague and specific asks

VagueSpecific
QuestionHow am I doing?In the report I sent yesterday, was the summary clear enough for the client?
TimingMonths after the workSoon after, while it is fresh
SettingIn the corridor, rushedA short chat booked in advance, or a brief message
AfterSay thanks and move onSay what you will try, then show it next time

Steps

  1. Pick one piece of work you want a view on.
  2. Ask one question about it, such as what to keep and what to change.
  3. Listen without defending. Write the points down and ask for an example if one is unclear.
  4. Say thank you and summarise what you heard to check you understood.
  5. Try one change in your next piece of work.
  6. Tell them what you changed, and ask whether it helped.

When the feedback is hard

Some feedback stings. Take a day before reacting and separate what is about the task from what you read into it. Practising a hard call helps too. Try a free decision on Compass and explain your reasoning to a friend for practice. Nobody scores you.

How to test it in a week

  1. Choose one task you finish this week, in a job, internship or college project.
  2. Ask someone who saw it one specific question.
  3. Write what you will change, and try it in the next task.

Common questions

What if my manager is too busy?

Ask a colleague who saw the work, or offer a two-line written question they can answer when free.

Where can I read more?

See how to use an internship to test a career and how to reflect after trying a career task.

Try the work before you choose it

Compass lets you try a realistic decision from each path you’re weighing, notice how it felt, and choose your next step with evidence. The preview on our home page is free.

Try a free decision

Weighing two or three paths seriously? See our packages, each prepared and reviewed by a person.

Related guides